The losses of the Republican Party in the U.S. midterm elections highlight the relationship between major media institutions and President Donald Trump, amid questions about the impact of political alignment on their editorial independence and credibility with the public.
The writer raises a question about the future of institutions that made editorial or institutional concessions over the past two years, and whether they can regain their independence and the public's trust after the political equation they relied on has changed.
Media concessions that are difficult to retract
Bartholomew reviews a series of decisions made by American media institutions during Trump's second presidency, considering that they reflect some owners' willingness to avoid confrontation with the U.S. administration.
He mentions ABC's decision to settle a defamation lawsuit filed by Trump following comments by broadcaster George Stephanopoulos regarding the E. Jean Carroll case, rather than continue litigation.
He also addresses billionaire Jeff Bezos's interventions in the editorial direction of the Washington Post, including limiting the editorial page's focus to defending individual liberties and free markets, along with layoffs that included a third of the newsroom staff.
CBS and the trust test with the public.
CBS News occupies a prominent position in Bartholomew's analysis, which discusses the transformations the network has undergone following the expanded influence of the Ellison family in the American media sector.
He points out that the media empire linked to the family has come to control CNN and CBS, along with other television and cinematic assets, and that these changes have reflected on the management of news organizations.
The article notes the performance of CBS News editor-in-chief, Bari Weiss, who had previously expressed her desire to provide content that appeals to Americans rejecting political propaganda from both the right and the left.
However, the writer indicates that her management faced accusations of softening critical coverage, which escalated to disputes over editorial intervention in the "60 Minutes" program, culminating in the dismissal of several of its correspondents last spring.
Among the names mentioned in the article are Sharyn Alfonsi and Scott Pelley, who transitioned to working as resident journalists at Columbia University's journalism school.
Bartholomew cites Nielsen's data showing CBS attracting around 2.8 million viewers during the evening coverage on election day, compared to 6.7 million for NBC, 5.2 million for ABC, 4.3 million for Fox News, 4.1 million for CNN, and 3.7 million for MS Now.
Although CBS's viewership increased compared to the 2022 elections, it came in last among the six networks, according to the figures cited in the article.
As for Fox News, it faces a more complicated dilemma, given its long relationship with Trump and its reliance on a conservative audience that forms a core base of its viewers.
CNN, MS Now, and Politico lawyers are engaged in a heated legal dispute over restrictions on journalists' access to certain White House facilities.